A new culture for a new year?
“We cannot always build the future for our youth, but we can build our youth for the future”
Readers of my last blog post will understand why I have taken time out to reflect on events, and on the personal impact these have had. During these weeks I have been lucky enough to spend time with the next generation of managers and clinical leaders – time which has been both energising and thought-provoking
* * *
In December I spoke at a Leadership Academy workshop where Graduate Management trainees were discussing, coincidentally, the emotional impact of healthcare management. An enlightened choice of topic, and one I believe is important given my own experiences
I find Graduate Management trainees to be an impressive bunch – they remind me of medical students, with whom they share a strong passion for a vocational career in which they can contribute positively to society
I shared my experiences of managing as both a clinician and CEO. We examined the challenge of balancing ‘hard’ responsibilities, such as financial balance or target achievement, with the so-called ‘softer’ ones of ensuring that service delivery incorporates compassion, kindness, and maintenance of dignity
Drawing on the work of Yvonne Sawbridge at Birmingham University we discussed the concept of ‘the emotional labour of managing’. We debated whether a manager who is emotionally aware, accessible and strongly attuned to patient and staff concerns, might be more vulnerable in the role than their less sensitive counterparts?
We reflected too on the harsh views the public have of managers, and the personal impact caused by campaigning politicians who seek to win public favour by promising to cut their numbers. Why is this, and how could this perception be changed?
I also spoke at two learning events for junior doctors. At one of these I met my long time Twitter friend Partha Kar, an established consultant but very much an up and coming leader. (He has already published his New Year reflections here). In both groups there was enthusiasm for improving the NHS, and a willingness to contribute, that was palpable
Look too at the comments on this blog from countless managers undertaking the excellent Elizabeth Garrett Anderson programme. These are managers with experience who are being developed towards senior leadership roles – they too demonstrate emotional intelligence and a strong focus on the patient
I came away from all these sessions feeling positive about the future, but my optimism was tempered. On each occasion, there was a sense in the room that they were powerless to influence the way the service is run and delivered. They knew that life can be uncomfortable for leaders who struggle to align with the culture of target chasing and harsh performance management, and they worried that it was ‘not for them’ because their values and approach did not fit with what they felt was expected. These reservations are also very evident in the comments on the EGA blog
Roy Lilley commented eloquently on this in his powerful end of year article. He talked of ‘management-by-intimidation’ and ‘institutionalised bullying’, and he supported his views with what he hears from his many readers, and with research evidence
* * *
I worry that we have a coming generation of clinicians and managers with a strong commitment to becoming senior leaders, and a preferred style and approach that is very much in tune with the thinking of both staff and public, but who are deterred by the prevailing culture?
It is, of course, this cohort who will determine the future standards of care and service to our patients and communities, so all those in senior positions have a responsibility to nurture and support them
The next generation ‘get’ the future, and can show us the way if we care to take notice. They instinctively understand that the ‘social era’ has arrived, meaning that connections and common purpose are more important than institutional isolation and vested interests, and that collaboration and co-creation will produce a better outcome than hierarchy and central direction
* * *
My New Year challenge to all those with influence is to heed the words of Roosevelt at the top of this article, and start building a new culture in the NHS through our up and coming leaders
Listen to them, and embrace their views and their values. Understand that a culture of dictat, inspection, penalties and blame demonstrates a lack of trust and belief in those charged with delivering services to patients, because it only makes sense as an approach if all performance shortfalls are caused by incompetent leadership
Instead, recognise that the most difficult challenges we face, such as the ‘winter crisis’, are highly complex and not anyone’s fault, and move towards a collective, problem-solving, approach in which support, empowerment and trust are watchwords
In closing…heartfelt thanks to the hundreds of people who sent me messages of support and encouragement in recent weeks. They were very much appreciated, and they have provided the basis of the challenge in this article
I will be continuing to write on this blog, and indeed to invite more guest writers, during 2015. It will have a new look soon, but keep the same web address
My Consulting site is under development, and will be separate
The Health Blog Round Up, run by my daughter and myself, is continuing, and will also be refreshed for 2015. Please do continue to let Emily know if you write a blog, or have seen a blog, that we can include
Thank you for your support, and very best wishes for 2015!